You're on the right track, though it has nothing to do with fairness. Like we've always said, none of you are real. Not in this universe, this galaxy. Someone like you, Mr. England, who is so bound to the physical reality of his universe, cannot sustain something like immortality in a universe you do not exist in.

[ The elevator door opens then, showing a... parking lot? Yes, it seems like a parking lot, one that is completely empty aside from a certain golf cart all the way on the other side of the room. Mosley gestures to England to follow him once again. ]

CERES is able to keep you here in Cerealia to exist as much as you possibly can while we restore your world. Of course, this isn't the full extent of your existence and why there are some oddities in the system, such as some people returning [ He air quotes this. ] "Home" for brief periods of time or some arriving here despite being dead back in their own reality but it's the best we can do given the restrictions currently in place. A half-life is better than a no-life, after all.