"I didn't say you did, Cole-san. If you took it, and kept it, then you'd be a thief. And I don't think you're a thief."

Honestly he seems a little too otherworldly to be one, with no real care for possessions except probably that hat.

"I don't know if you can learn something by losing a memory, though. Maybe that's one problem. But sometimes there are secrets nobody is meant to learn, don't you think?"

She's actually pretty confused, not following his train of thought, but she's trying to keep up.